Meet the Diane McConaghy Team

Moving Right Along

We are a team of driven, full-time Realtors / Real estate Agents who are known for our extensive market knowledge and unmatched devotion to clients.

Our success is based on our positive referrals, integrity, and providing quality, professional Real Estate services. We earn the respect of our clients by working tirelessly on their behalf and by always offering candid advice.

We have a passion for selling Real Estate in Western PA, living our full and best lives and helping our clients make their real estate dreams a reality.

Meet the team


Diane McConaghy - Diane McConaghy Team

Office: (724) 933-6300 x 826
Mobile: (412) 719-7732

Diane was born and raised in the Pgh area and is a graduate of Point Park College. She spent over 30 years in Corporate America, with the last 15 years as Procurement Director negotiating contracts in the pharmaceuticals and healthcare industries.

Diane pursued a career in Real Estate in 2013, and during her first year, received her Master’s Accreditation and achieved President’s Club and Rookie of the Year status.  Since then, Diane has obtained her Real Estate Broker's licence and has continued to receive multiple awards and exceed all plans each year.

Diane is a highly motivated, hard-working, and extremely organized Full-TimeAssociate Broker / Realtor® with a positive approach to understanding customer needs. Regardless of your real estate challenge, she is able to capitalize on years of negotiating experience and provide personalized service to guide her clients through every step of the process.

Diane lives in Robinson Twp with her three children, 2 dogs - Neela & Murphy. She is one of 9 children with 20 nieces and nephews. Diane loves bicycling, photography and singing in two church choirs. She is a regular volunteer/supporter for Light of Life Ministries and is involved with the communities her team serves by providing Free advertising for small businesses.

Untitled design (1)

Ally Wagoner - Diane McConaghy Team

Office: (724) 933-6300 x 826
Mobile: (412) 849-4167

Ally was born in Rhode Island but grew up in Pittsburgh where she graduated from Montour High School. She completed her Bachelors degree at West Virginia University where she earned a B.S. in Psychology.

In 2012, Ally began her real estate career in title and settlement. Here she learned the in’s and out’s of real estate transactions. She also has years of experience in property management and leasing. With ample experience in the industry, Ally is a well-rounded agent who has developed a true knowledge of real estate beneficial to both buyers and sellers.

Ally prides herself on being accessible to her clients. She’s diligent, tenacious, and is highly effective at negotiating and communication. Ally has a true passion for the real estate profession and a commitment to her clients. Her dedication and expertise will see you through the entire process.

In addition to being a full-time Realtor, Ally also enjoys spending time with her family. She is the mother of a young son and has two fur baby dogs as well! Being settled near her roots in the western side of the city, they take advantage of everything Pittsburgh! Let her help you today!


Sarah Fitzpatrick - Diane McConaghy Team

Office: (724) 933-6300 x 826
Mobile: (724) 601-0026

Sarah was born in the Pittsburgh area, though spent much of her youth in upstate NY. She graduated from the California University of PA where she earned a B.S. in Psychology.

The majority of Sarah's Real Estate career thus far has been spent in Property Management, both leasing, and managing. For the last five years, she successfully managed Pittsburgh’s largest residential community for one of the city’s premier management companies. Her passion and dedication to her property, her residents, and her employees made her a top leader in her industry.

The choice to step into a full-time position as the newest member of the Diane McConaghy Team was an easy one, allowing Sarah the time and freedom to solely focus on her clients and their experience. Her sunny disposition and ability to seamlessly solve problems makes working with Sarah is a graceful process every step of the way.

Outside of work, she lives a quiet, peaceful life in Castle Shannon with the love of her life and their chihuahua.


Samantha Kelly - Diane McConaghy Team

Office: 724-933-6300 x826
Mobile: 412-508-9438

Samantha was born and raised in Pittsburgh and is a graduate of Montour High School. She has spent most of her career working & volunteering in her hometown.

Samantha recently worked for a corporate bank teaching her clients money management tools and helping those clients meet their financial goals, including purchasing their first homes.

She has decided to continue her passion for helping others and follow in her mother's footsteps by becoming the newest member and full-time Real Estate Agent with the Diane McConaghy Team.

Already a small successful business owner, Samantha has the advantage of a strong commitment with her clients.   She is driven by the success of her mother and her team. She is resilient & dedicated to whatever she sets her mind to.

In her free time, Samantha enjoys being outdoors, cooking, baking and anything DIY. She loves being around people and her two dogs, Murphy & Neela.


Karen Rush - Diane McConaghy Team

Office: (724) 933-6300 x826

Karen was born in the Pittsburgh area where she graduated from Slippery Rock University with a Bachelor’s Degree in Education. She then went on to receive her Master’s Degree in Education and Sports Medicine from West Virginia University.

Karen taught Health and Physical Education at Fort Cherry High School for 35 years. After retiring in 2017, Karen became a substitute teacher in her local school district and has worked part-time for a catering business for the past 10 years.

The Team relies on Karen to coordinate efforts between all parties throughout the real estate selling and buying process. In the role of Transaction Coordinator, she understands that timeliness and accessibility are especially important qualities and ensures that all deadlines are met. Karen is a motivated, hard-working, and caring woman who will do whatever it takes to make sure that each of our clients walks away pleasantly satisfied with their interaction with the Diane McConaghy Team.

Karen lives in Wheeling, West Virginia with her daughter and two sons. She loves cooking and baking and regularly attends her children’s activities.

Scroll to Top